Posted by Tony Z. on February 21, 2003 at 00:01:16:
In Reply to: 8va heros posted by JS on February 20, 2003 at 23:02:11:
n all seriousness, there are times when the low octave IS called for. Sometimes the melodic element of the bass line is disrupted by an obvious octave leap up because the composer didn't understand, or just didn't have the equipment (as Joe stated,) but there are also times when the harmonic structure cries for it. As long as the note is not ridiculous (i.e. those undulating G's and such) it can go a long way to furthering the resonance of a given harmonic series. I am an admitted "8va Hero" wannabe on occasion, but I do use common sense before I don the cape:
1. Don't overdo it!! It loses its impact!! (be judicious!!)
2. Make sure that the octave immediately above is present (tell the other guy to stay, or have the bass 'bone take it down) ;)
3. Make sure that it isn't contrary to the composer's INTENT. You'll know if you pay attention!
4. Check with the conductor...it makes them feel good.
Foremost in my mind, as a conductor, performer and composer, don't ruin the music!! That's why we're here anyhow, isn't it?
My humble thoughts...
TZ